twerfs like to think that what unites cis women together are their experiences of womanhood, and that their experience is “pure” and that no trans woman can ever come close to that, or be included in that unity since they weren’t assigned female at birth, and that is pure unadulterated bullcrap.
not only is it transphobic to disregard trans womanhood, but it’s also racist and classist and ableist and all other kinds of shit. all women haven’t had the same experience. an abled white middle class cis lesbian from new york has most definitely had a very different experience regarding womanhood than a cis woman living in australia who is aboriginal and lower class and disabled.
life experiences aren’t simple and black-and-white, they aren’t identical just because two people were assigned the same gender at birth, they have different shades and tones. womanhood isn’t rooted in having a vulva or being able to give birth. womanhood is a part of you that you can adopt and cherish and love, or not think about and just go with.
there is no sense in trying to exclude trans women from your women’s group because her experience is different from yours, since all womens experiences differentiate. what you actually need is to unite all women to have deep discussions about what being a woman is to you, and how being a woman has affected you and how it makes you happy, and to fall in love with the diversity of the experiences and lives and journeys you’ve all had to become the woman you are now, regardless of your assigned at birth status.


